Evidence for the Existence of God - The Ontological Argument

This week I am going to help you to do a little brain exercising. The ontological argument has been an argument that has intrigued me from the first time I heard it 20 years ago as a Moody Bible Institute student. Now, some of you are going to think I am weird for making that statement and others will probably do so after familiarizing yourself with the argument. I also know that many in the New Atheist camp like Richard Dawkins give it short shrift in their books, but there are a lot of bright young philosophers who are building on the work of people like Alvin Plantinga and the argument has gained new attention.

I just finished a class in Philosophy of Religion during which I re-read Alvin Plantinga's treatment of the ontological argument. Now, if you are ever having a problem with pride because you think you are really smart, I would suggest that you read an article from Plantinga, I am sure that it will plant your feet back on Terra firma. I did a brief synopsis of Plantiga's treatment of the ontological argument and will review it below:

Overview of the argument

1. There is a world W in which there exists a being with maximal greatness.

2. A being has maximal greatness in a world only if it exists in every possible world.

3. The property has maximal greatness entails the property has maximal excellence in every possible world.

4. Maximal excellence entails omniscience, omnipotence, and moral perfection.

5. Maximal greatness is possibly exemplified.

6. There is a world W* and an essence E* such that E* is exemplified in W* and E* entails has maximal greatness in W*

7. For any object x, if x exemplifies E*, then x exemplifies the property has maximal excellence in every possible world.

8. If W* had been actual, it would have been impossible that E* fail to be exemplified.

9. There exists a being that has maximal excellence in every world.

Argument explained

I think that it is helpful to look at his premises (numbered) and conclusions on their own without the related commentary. I find that the key to Plantinga's argument is that he states it somewhat differently from what I have heard before in that his initial statement is:

1. There is a world W in which there exists a being with maximal greatness.

This statement, I believe puts the skeptic in the defensive position of trying to prove that this world could not exist. Plantinga goes on:

2. A being has maximal greatness in a world only if it exists in every possible world.

A fancy way of saying that if this being exists, this being would have to exist where ever existence could happen. This would be true since a being that existed in every possible world would certainly be greater than a being that only existed in a limited number of possible worlds.

3. The property has maximal greatness entails (results in) the property has maximal excellence in every possible world.

Simply stated, if the being is maximally great, it has the property of maximal greatness in every possible existence.

4. Maximal excellence entails omniscience, omnipotence, and moral perfection.

Omniscience (maximal knowledge or seeing), omnipotence (maximal power), moral perfection (self-explanatory) are qualities we would expect from a maximally great being.

5. Maximal greatness is possibly exemplified.

The first of these statements seem fairly straightforward and non-controversial. The second is definitional as to what is entailed in maximal greatness and, although it is not a comprehensive definition, it also seems not to be controversial. The third statement is the one that a skeptic may push back on. However, they are still in the defensive position showing why this could not possibly be the case.

6. There is a world W* and an essence E* such that E* is exemplified in W* and E* entails has maximal greatness in W*

So, what he is saying is that there is a possible world in which an essence, has maximal greatness entails or would be exhibited. This is a follow on to the prior statement and just showing that a possible world could exist where this essence would entail. The skeptic is still on the defensive to prove otherwise.

7. For any object x, if x exemplifies E*, then x exemplifies the property has maximal excellence in every possible world.

So, if an object exemplified the essence that was described in the previous step, it would follow that that object would exemplify maximal excellence in every possible world. In other words, going back to his previous description that maximal greatness would be exhibited in every possible world (for otherwise it would be limited and not maximal), and maximal greatness exhibits maximal excellence, therefore maximal excellence would be exhibited in every possible world.

8. If W* had been actual, it would have been impossible that E* fail to be exemplified.

This just means that if possible world W* actually existed, then E* (maximal greatness) would have to be exemplified in that world. This relates back to #6. So, since there is a possible world in which E* is exemplified and, therefore, by definition established in the argument, E* entails maximal greatness and maximal greatness would be exhibited in every possible world, then,

9. There exists a being that has maximal excellence in every world.

Here is where brains can melt down and people throw up their hands, scratch their heads and say "huh?" But keep reading until it sinks in and you will almost visibly see the light bulb go on and should say aloud, "Aha!". The conclusion is that if that possible world exists where the maximally great being exists and, by definition that being would exist in all possible worlds since that follows from maximal greatness. Since it is impossible for E* (maximal greatness) not to be exemplified in W* (a possible world), then if follows that it is impossible for E* to be exemplified in every possible world, therefore, that being exists and that being is God.

Again, it is worth pondering this argument until it makes sense to you. If you still find yourself scratching your head and in utter confusion, feel free to drop me an email and I will try to clarify it further. Now that you have had your minds exercised,go take a cool down lap outside in the fresh air!

Wall-E and Me

This week the discussion in our Interfaith group centered on the idea of the mind and whether someone like the cute little robots in Wall-E could ever experience true love or whether Data from Star Trek TNG would ever become human, even if they put in that emotion chip. What separates man from machine? Could my computer ever develop a free will with the right programing and hardware? I hope not, I have enough trouble with it as it is!

This is a key question in the whole debate over naturalistic evolution, what is the mind and how does it work? Some of the key figures in the debate from an evolutionary perspective are Daniel Dennett from Tufts and John Searle from U.C. Berkeley. Dennett and Searle are naturalists/physicalists, in other words, they believe that the totality of existence is contained within the physical universe. Now, they each have different approaches to attempt to explain mind; however, in each case mind is ultimately an emanation from the brain and not an entity unto itself. This position, however, leads to many difficulties that neither has successfully overcome. I won't be able to go through all of the problems, nor would you patiently read through the whole post if I did, but here are a few.

First, there is the problem of how to understand mental states in the first place. Some in this camp would reduce mental states down to the physical. In other words, the mind is just a emanation or extension of the brain. This runs into all kinds of difficulties as far as how to understand identity, intentionality, and ultimately, morality. For, if a persons actions are merely determined by their biology, then no one can ultimately be held accountable for his or her actions. Yet, we see more and more of this playing out in our society today.

Second, I mentioned intentionality in the previous point; however, it is a problem of its own. When my brain tells me to lift my thumb or type on my computer, we aren't really challenged by that thought. However, when you begin to add steps and branches and sub steps to arrive at an intended destination, this is where it runs into problems. For example, if my intention was to go to work so that I could complete a proposal, I would have to get up, get ready for work, drive my car through a series of streets, roads and highways to get to work, go into my office, turn on my computer, log in, start my word processing program, find the file, and search for the place where I left off. This series of steps does not seem unusual to us, yet this poses massive problems for a physicalist since it involves so many sub intentions to arrive at the goal of writing my proposal. There is a real challenge trying to figure out how a person can have intentions that are far removed from immediate actions, something that we just take for granted.

Third, concepts like truth are ultimately meaningless if all we are can be reduced down to physical properties. There is no reason that we could be confident that we know truth if we are simply acting according to causal events directed by our biology. Why would we be confident that our biology led us to truth rather than just to that which will allow us to survive another few minutes? If we are finite creature stuck within a finite existence, then we should have no confidence at all in this regard.

These issues are overcome in a theistic worldview as mind is separate but related to the physical body. God is the eternal mind who has created us in his image (Imago Dei) and given us characteristics that allow us to be in relationship with him. He has instilled us with personality, will and characteristics related to these. This is why when I tell my wife or my kids that I love them it cannot be reduced down to some physical properties of my brain or body, but is something real and meaningful that I am expressing. When I choose to do something right or wrong, I am making a real choice with real consequences. Also, we serve a God who came to live among us by taking on human flesh. Jesus told Pilate, "you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free." (John 8:32) Jesus understood that truth could be known. He also demonstrated that we are more than more than just physical bodies by rising from the dead. However, even intuitively, we understand that we are more than just physical beings. Our love is real love. Our emotions are real emotions. Our thoughts cannot be reduced to physical mere physical properties. We are more than just the sum of our parts.

Psalm 139

1
O LORD, you have searched me and known me! 2You know when I sit down and when I rise up;
you discern my thoughts from afar.
3You search out my path and my lying down
and are acquainted with all my ways.
4Even before a word is on my tongue,
behold, O LORD, you know it altogether.
5You hem me in, behind and before,
and lay your hand upon me.
6 Such knowledge is too wonderful for me;
it is high; I cannot attain it.

13For you formed my inward parts;
you knitted me together in my mother’s womb.
14I praise you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. Wonderful are your works;
my soul knows it very well.
15 My frame was not hidden from you,when I was being made in secret,
intricately woven in the depths of the earth.
16Your eyes saw my unformed substance;in your book were written, every one of them,
the days that were formed for me,
when as yet there was none of them.

17How precious to me are your thoughts, O God!
How vast is the sum of them!
18 If I would count them, they are more than the sand.
I awake, and I am still with you.

Evidence for the Existence of God -Truth

Here is an interesting argument that philosopher Peter Kreeft puts forth that ties into our discussion of the existence of the mind and truth. Kreeft derives this argument from Augustine and puts it this way,

  1. Our limited minds can discover eternal truths about being.
  2. Truth properly resides in a mind.
  3. But the human mind is not eternal.
  4. Therefore there must exist an eternal mind in which these truths reside.


Kreeft explains that this argument appeals to those who hold to a Platonic view of knowledge based on his use of forms. Forms are abstract entities or ideas that exist independently of us. Ideas like truth, perfection, equal, etc. are concepts that we understand even though we may never have seen them in their completion. An example given would be two things that appear equal; however, if we were to examine them more closely and precisely, we would find differences in them. Yet, we still understand the concept of equal. Kreeft explains that this view holds that there are "are Eternal Intelligible Forms which are present to the mind in every act of knowledge.[1] If these concepts are within our finite minds, Kreeft argues that it is a short step to conclude that they reside within an eternal mind beyond ours. He basically leaves the argument there as it is much too detailed to get into it in anything less than a full length book.

Professor Angus Menuge cites Harvard professor of psychology, Steven Pinker who wrote, "our brains were shaped for fitness, not for truth.”[2] Menuge goes on to summarize Pinker’s idea by saying, “our cognitive capacities, including reason, are there because they are useful in the Darwinian sense of promoting the flourishing of our "selfish" genes.” The bottom line is that, according to a naturalist/evolutionary model, our brains aren’t wired so much for truth as they are for survival. Truth is not necessary as long as what we know and believe leads us to make decisions that promote survival.

Menuge goes on to say that evolution simply tests us for our behavior and that false believes are as good as true ones as long as the right behavior is produced, that is, behavior that leads to survival. He quotes from Lewis Wolpert’s book, Six Impossible Things Before Breakfast, where he states, "our brains contain a belief generating machine, an engine that can produce beliefs with little relation to what is actually true."[3]

Even the scientific method, the core of truth claims for a materialist, is based upon core truth claims that cannot be scientifically verified in and of themselves. These include the principle of causality, uniformity, and others.

So, for these and other reasons we are led to understand that truth exists and that it is not simply an outworking of an evolutionary framework, but is required to understand any scientific framework. If truth exists, then it is a short step to believe that an eternal and objective source of truth exists – God. I will write more on this later as I am reading some interesting work on how truth and beauty point us toward an ultimate designer.



[1] Peter Kreeft, “Twenty Arguments For The Existence Of God”; available from http://www.peterkreeft.com/topics-more/20_arguments-gods-existence.htm

[2] " Steven Pinker, How the Mind Works, New York, W.W. Norton & Co., 1999, 305. As found in Angus Menuge, “Truth and Usefulness”; available from http://www.epsociety.org/blog/2008/11/truth-and-usefulness.asp.

[3] Lewis Wolpert, Six Impossible Things Before Breakfast: The Evolutionary Origins of Belief, New York, W.W. Norton & Co., 1977, 140. Ibid.

Celebrating the Resurrection

I had a conversation last night with some friends of mine, one of whom is a Muslim. I had the opportunity to explain to them the significance of the life, death, burial and resurrection of Jesus Christ. This led to a number of questions from Fatemeh, a Muslim who is schooled in her faith. She asked how God could become less than he is by becoming a man. She asked how God could be three persons. She asked how the Old Testament prophets could have sinned. These and others are common questions asked by Muslims and are put forth as logical contradictions; however, when probed more deeply, they are not contradictions at all. First, when we say that God is one in being yet three persons, we often get confused with humans who are one in being and person for the most part. In listening to William Lane Craig answer questions of a person who was engaged in a conversation with a Muslim, he answered the question this way. God is one, yet with three separate and distinct centers of consciousness. Those centers of consciousness are the three persons of the godhead. This was a bit difficult for Fatemeh to understand partly due to her Muslim biases and partly due to language barriers, but I think she at least understood what I was saying.

Regarding the question of Jesus becoming a man, and therefore in her estimation, less than God, here is how I answered that question. As we read in Philippians 2, Jesus took on the nature of a man; however, in doing this he didn't become less than God, but simply added a human nature to his divine nature. So, Jesus didn't become 50% man and 50% God, or any other breakdown that would add up ultimately to only 100%. He was 100% God and 100% man, fully encompassing both natures without those natures intermixing or being in any way separable. This issue was debated at the Council of Chalcedon in 451 A.D. which produced the following statement:

Following the holy Fathers, we unanimously teach and confess one and the same Son, our Lord Jesus Christ: the same perfect in divinity and perfect in humanity, the same truly God and truly man, composed of rational soul and body; consubstantial with the Father as to his divinity and consubstantial with us as to his humanity; "like us in all things but sin." He was begotten from the Father before all ages as to his divinity and in these last days, for us and for our salvation, was born as to his humanity of the virgin Mary, the Mother of God.

We confess that one and the same Christ, Lord, and only-begotten Son, is to be acknowledged in two natures without confusion, change, division, or separation (in duabus naturis inconfuse, immutabiliter, indivise, inseparabiliter). The distinction between natures was never abolished by their union, but rather the character proper to each of the two natures was preserved as they came together in one person (prosopon) and one hypostasis.

I also explained that though the Old Testament prophets sinned, for which the Bible gives plenty of evidence, they had the same opportunity as Christians do today to have their sins covered through their trust in God. They sacrificed animals at the Temple as a temporary covering of their sins, yet the blood of those animals was always temporary; Jesus on the other hand, was the final offering - the Lamb who takes away the sins of the world!

Fatemeh's last question had to do with God's justice. She believed that Christianity was not based on a view of a just God. I that it was quite the contrary; that every other religion is based upon works as a means of earning ones salvation; however, I explained that this diminishes God's holiness in that we could sin against an eternal God and pay it off with finite and temporal payments. I explained that only God himself was capable of paying the debt that we owed, in that only God was capable of paying for an infinite debt. In Islam, God would have to ultimately overlook sins committed against him by accepting good works as payment. This is true of every other religion as well as all others are ultimately works based. So, it is Christianity that is built of perfect justice, as well as perfect grace and mercy.

I hope you will ponder these ideas as you celebrate the resurrection of our sin-bearer, Jesus. He is Risen...He is Risen, Indeed!

Evidence for the Existence of God - Consciousness

I thought that I would address this argument as it came into the conversation that I was having with Nate on Thursday night. This issue is a major challenge for materialists/naturalists as it is difficult, if not impossible to explain why and how we have consciousness if all that we are are walking chemical reactors. How does consciousness arise from non-consciousness (to be distinguished from unconsciousness).

Although consciousness has many different aspects to it, we will look at a few that are germane to this discussion. The first idea is that of sentience which Armstrong describes as being "capable of sensing and responding to its world." We would think of this response as more than a mere involuntary reaction. A deeper level of this idea is that of self-consciousness, which the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy describes "as those that are not only aware but also aware that they are aware." When we look at the world and are aware of it and aware of our place in the world, that becomes a state that requires explanation. We know things about ourselves that no other human will even know unless we tell them. So, how do we explain this?

Philosopher Peter Kreeft makes the following argument:

  1. We experience the universe as intelligible. This intelligibility means that the universe is graspable by intelligence.
  2. Either this intelligible universe and the finite minds so well suited to grasp it are the products of intelligence, or both intelligibility and intelligence are the products of blind chance.
  3. Not blind chance.
  4. Therefore this intelligible universe and the finite minds so well suited to grasp it are the products of intelligence.

The questions that this argument include: why should the universe appear to be intelligible by us if it is the product of chance?; how does the impersonal take on personal qualities?; or, are those personal qualities illusion?; does the outside world really exist, or are we merely part of a larger illusion? These may seem like silly questions to some of you; however, these questions and others have plagued thinkers for generations, and continue to do so.

The direction that may have gone is to pursue pantheism as the lowest possible entry point into a non-material reality. Why pantheism? Well, first of all it answers how the material world can experience a non-material reality - mind. Second, it is a spiritual step that does not put many requirements on its adherents. The god(s) of pantheism are generally not those who would require anything of its/their adherents, rather, the adherent can control the gods. Think back to the Star Wars movies and how Obi-Wan Kenobi teaches Luke Skywalker to harness the force to his advantage. What was that force, nothing other than a pantheistic representation of god, a god who could be controlled and manipulated to one's advantage. A god that also had a light side (pursued by Luke) and a dark side (pursued by Darth Vader).

The God of the Bible is a God that, by his very nature, deserves and commands our worship and obedience, not as a dictator, but as a loving ruler who created us in His image and desires what is best for us. However, as C.S. Lewis wrote in the Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe of Aslan, the representation of Christ in his series:

“Is -- is he a man?” asked Lucy. “Aslan a man!” said Mr. Beaver sternly. “Certainly not. I tell you he is the King
of wood and the son of the great Emperor-Beyond-the-Sea. Don't you know who is the King of the Beasts?
Aslan is a lion -- the Lion, the great Lion.” “Ooh,” said Susan, “I thought he was a man. Is he -- quite safe? I
shall feel rather nervous about meeting a lion.” “That you will, dearie, and make no mistake,” said Mrs.
Beaver, “if there's anyone who can appear before Aslan without their knees knocking, they're either braver
than most or else silly.” “Then he isn't safe?” said Lucy. “Safe?” said Mr. Beaver, “don't you hear what Mrs.
Beaver tells you? Who said anything about safe? 'Course he isn't safe. But he's good. He's the King, I tell
you.”

God has given us consciousness and minds such that we could know Him, love Him, and worship Him. He has also given us self-awareness so that we could know ourselves, and by doing so, to know our true need for redemption from our fallen condition. Our salvation is not to look within, as so many tell us to do, and as Obi-Wan told Luke to do, but to look above and beyond ourselves to the great God who created us to be in relationship with Himself.

Psalm 123

1To you I lift up my eyes,
O you who are enthroned in the heavens!
2Behold, as the eyes of servants
look to the hand of their master,
as the eyes of a maidservant
to the hand of her mistress,
so our eyes look to the LORD our God,
till he has mercy upon us.

3 Have mercy upon us, O LORD, have mercy upon us,
for we have had more than enough of contempt.
4Our soul has had more than enough
of the scorn of those who are at ease,
of the contempt of the proud.

Evidence for the Existence of God - Aesthetic Beauty

I know that I wrote about aesthetic beauty a few weeks ago; however, it is actually a very effective argument for the existence of God. I was thinking about this argument as I sat through my daughters' piano recital today. As you might expect, my daughters performed the pieces that they selected to play beautifully, as did the other 25 performers. Of special treat at these events are the performances of the Billingham kids, two sons and a daughter of Dr. William Billingham, the assistant conductor of the Lyric Opera of Chicago. They are also trained by our daughters' piano instructor. A few times, including today, we have had the opportunity to hear Dr. Billingham play a duet with one or both of his sons. Today he played Mozart's Concerto, No. 20, K 466 (I. Allegro) with his younger son, Adam and Mendelssohn's Concerto, No. 1, Op. 25 (I. Molto allegro con fuoco) with his older son, Josh. The recital was held at our nearby Steinway music store on two Steinway concert grand pianos (retail value of $130,000 each).

As you can imagine, it was a beautiful and emotional experience to hear them play together. As I sat there, I could only wonder why, if we are the product of random processes and natural selection as many would have us to believe these days, would this music even exist, let alone move a person to emotion? It really doesn't make any sense at all as it does nothing to add to our survival as a species. It doesn't gather any more food for us (although we did have snacks afterward - but we, the parents even brought those), it doesn't lead to an increase in the population, and the lessons actually cost money, as do the instruments on which the music is played. It just seems nonsensical that people would create music that has order and does something to us that we identify as emotions, which themselves don't make sense from an evolutionary viewpoint.

Boston College professor of philosophy, Dr. Peter Kreeft developed a simple, but thought provoking argument for the existence of God on which I will leave you to ponder. It is a short argument in number of words, but a deep argument in the ideas that it can evoke. Here it is:

Premise: There is the music of Johann Sebastian Bach (or, you could substitute Mozart, Mendelssohn, Beethoven, or any number of classical composers)

Conclusion: Therefore there must be a God.

Kreeft finishes this argument by saying, "You either see this one or you don't." I hope you get it. Today was a reminder that I do.

Evidence for the Existence of God - Argument from Contingency

One argument for the existence of God that I have overlooked up to this point is the argument from contingency. It is a very strong argument and one that may take some thinking through to properly grasp the concepts. The argument traces back to Thomas Aquinas and was discussed later by philosopher Gottfried Leibniz (1646-1716) who asked the question, "Why is there something rather than nothing?" He continued, "After all, nothing is simpler and easier than something. Also, given that things have to exist, we must be able to give a reason why they have to exist as they are and not otherwise." (The Principles of Nature and of Grace, Based on Reason) The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy states the formal argument as follows:

  1. A contingent being (a being that if it exists can not-exist) exists.
  2. This contingent being has a cause of or explanation for its existence.
  3. The cause of or explanation for its existence is something other than the contingent being itself.
  4. What causes or explains the existence of this contingent being must either be solely other contingent beings or include a non-contingent (necessary) being.
  5. Contingent beings alone cannot provide an adequate causal account or explanation for the existence of a contingent being.
  6. Therefore, what causes or explains the existence of this contingent being must include a non-contingent (necessary) being.
  7. Therefore, a necessary being (a being that if it exists cannot not-exist) exists.

Now, from this argument we can look to science and philosophy to see that all material things are contingent upon something or someone else for their existence. So in this argument, unlike the Kalam Cosmological Argument, we are not looking for a cause of existence, but an explanation of existence. That explanation is either found outside of itself or found within itself. When we look at physical objects we know from philosophy and science that the explanation is always found outside of the object. The reason of my existence is found in the fact that my father and mother gave life to me. I am a contingent being. The reason for that my house exists in found in the builders, etc.

The skeptic will generally accept premises 1-3, but will attack premise 4. However, I have often heard atheists try to argue that the universe just exists as a brute fact. To that objection, philosopher William Lane Craig gives the following illustration to show the absurdity of denying that the universe is a contingent entity simply due to its immensity.

Imagine that you’re hiking through the woods one day and you come across a translucent ball lying on the forest floor. You would naturally wonder how it came to be there. If one of your hiking partners said to you, “It just exists inexplicably. Don’t worry about it!”, you’d either think that he was crazy or figure that he just wanted you to keep moving. No one would take seriously the suggestion that the ball existed there with literally no explanation.

Now suppose you increase the size of the ball in this story so that it’s the size of a car. That wouldn’t do anything to satisfy or remove the demand for an explanation. Suppose it were the size of a house. Same problem. Suppose it were the size of a continent or a planet. Same problem. Suppose it were the size of the entire universe. Same problem. Merely increasing the size of the ball does nothing to affect the need of an explanation. Reasonable Faith.org, Q&A Question #25: Argument from Contingency

So, the point is that just because an object is large doesn't lessen the liklihood of it being contingent upon something or someone else as the cause. Skeptics will also attack premise #3 by referring to philosopher David Hume who denied the validity of the principle of causality. However, denying the principle of causality is to ultimately deny the validity of science, which rests on this principle. Think about trying to prove anything scientifically if we couldn't count on causality and uniformity. Doctors would be out of business. Science would be akin to magic. Imagine what life would be like.

The argument also rests on the logical impossibility of an infinite regress of temporal causes. Stephen Hawking illustrates the absurdity of this concept in his book A Brief History of Time:

A well known scientist (some say it was Bertrand Russell) once gave a public lecture on astronomy. He described how the earth orbits around the sun and how the sun, in turn, orbits around the center of a vast collection of stars called our galaxy. At the end of the lecture, a little old lady at the back of the room got up and said: “What you have told us is rubbish. The world is really a flat plate supported on the back of a giant tortoise.” The scientist gave a superior smile before replying, “What is the tortoise standing on.” “You’re very clever, young man, very clever,” said the old lady. “But it’s turtles all the way down!”

The argument goes back to the absurdity of having an actually instantiated infinite, which Craig and others argue is logically absurd. Craig argues that if you do things like divide an infinite in half, you still end up with an infinite. Or, if you subtract all odd numbers from an infinite set, you still end up with an infinite set. The second problem is that if there is no first cause, there are no subsequent causes, and to argue for an infinite series of causes/effects is to say that there is no ultimate first cause and therefore, no ultimate explanation for the effects in our world.

So what is the explanation of a necessary being? Simply, a necessary being is one whose existence is explained within himself and who cannot not be. We have two possible explanations for the universe, either it is a necessary entity, which most scientists, even atheists, would argue; or, it is the effect of a necessary cause, which would be God. If you want a more detailed explanation of this argument, I suggest that you click on the two links contained within this post for more information.